3 Powerful Ways to Get Your Monthly Donors to Give More

A few weeks ago, I published the post “How to Get Last Year’s Donors to Give More this Year.” Guest blogger Joe Garecht shared some great advice for increasing giving. However, the post did not specifically address the issue of monthly giving. That led to a reader comment.

Larry Little, President of Guardian Angel Basset Rescue, raised some important questions:

Our revenues are in the $300k range but approximately 30% of that comes through our monthly giving program. My question is about asking monthly donors to increase their amounts. How often should that be done? And should you segment your list and ask that segment every 18 months?”

First, I want to congratulate Little for having a robust monthly-giving program. Well done!

Second, I thank Little for inspiring this week’s post. While I could have given him a quick, brief response, I realized the topic deserves more attention and that it would likely be of interest to many of my readers. So, I invited expert Erica Waasdorp, President of A Direct Solution and author of the best-selling book Monthly Giving: The Sleeping Giant, to share her wisdom to help us better understand how to inspire greater giving from monthly supporters. I thank her for her insights:


It’s wonderful to see how much the focus is shifting to monthly giving, and it’s starting to really pay off for nonprofit organizations. Here are just two recent statistics from the most recent Blackbaud Luminate Online Benchmark Report:

Expanding relationships with existing supporters was the name of the game this year as we saw a 20.4% growth in sustainer revenue.”

Viewing online revenue as one great big pie, we saw a larger slice of the pie—8.4% more—coming from sustainer gifts in 2017.”

Today, I’m not going to write about how to convert your donors to give monthly. Today, I’m going to focus on how to generate more money from your existing monthly donors.

Just because they’re now giving more money than as single-gift givers doesn’t mean it ends there. Oh no! There are three ways you can actually ask your monthly donors to give more money:

1.      Ask for a monthly upgrade.

2.      Ask for an additional gift.

3.      Ask for a legacy gift.

Ask for a monthly upgrade.

People typically ask me two questions: A) How soon after a donor starts giving monthly can I ask for an upgrade? B) How often can I ask for an upgrade?

Before I address the timing questions, let me just point out that donors upgrade because they have been stewarded effectively. Totally true. And this also pertains to monthly donors. That’s why I always “hammer” on the importance of sending a hard-copy thank-you recognition letter even if the monthly donor came in online.

So let’s assume that you’ve done this part right. And let’s assume that your donor gives monthly through his or her credit card. And let’s assume that you send the donor a quarterly newsletter with some great stories and updates on how the donor’s giving makes a difference.

I’ve seen organizations that started to upgrade right away. I’ve seen organizations that started to upgrade three months after a monthly donor joined. Frankly, I think that’s just too soon. Yes, you may get some donors to upgrade when you ask, but I think you’d also come across as much greedier than you may wish to. That could alienate some supporters.

Your donor has just started to get used to giving monthly. They’re just getting acquainted with your stewardship efforts. They have just started to realize the convenience of giving this way.

You pay taxes typically once a year; you update your budget once a year, so I suggest asking for an upgraded amount once a year, ideally between 10 to 12 months after the donor gave monthly for the first time. That’s when you can make a legitimate case for the increase in cost for xyz service, and ask the donor if he can “give just a few dollars more a month” to help the children/client/animals.

And, as Joe Garecht mentioned in his earlier post, the four elements of asking monthly donors to increase their monthly gift are indeed:

1. Thank your donors for their past support.

2.  Show donors how they’ve made an impact.

3.  Explain why you need more money.

4.  Make the ask.

The beauty of asking for the upgrade is that it will help you validate the donor’s credit card information as well so that will help with your retention. A combination of email, mail, and phone works best; and you can do all of the above.  Base the ask on what the donor has given. In other words, if they’re giving $50 a month, you could try a $10 or $15 a month upgrade. If they give $5 a month, you could go for $1 or $2 dollars more. The one-third rule tends to work well here.

One word of caution! I know there are some organizations that started the automatic upgrade practice, where they literally upgrade the donors’ gift with $2 or $3 dollars a month, and then just send the donor a letter that this is what they’ve done. This is not what the donor signed up for. PLEASE, PLEASE, do not consider this practice, even with the use of fine-print. All it takes is one donor who gets so upset that it could damage our whole fundraising world as we know it.

Trust me; you’ll actually raise more money if you ask the donor what they’d like to do. Let’s always think about the donor! A monthly donor trusts you with their information, so let’s keep that trust.

Ask for an additional gift.

Look at your overall communication stream and see which of your appeals are most successful and perhaps even desirable for your monthly donors. For example, if you have an annual calendar, make that at least the one appeal you send to your monthly donors.

Always include a reference to the fact that you know that the donor is already giving monthly. It can be done in the letter or it can be done as a little insert or, if you’re a smaller organization, you can handwrite a personal note.

I know that animal and religious organizations tend to be able to get away with sending multiple additional-gift appeals a year without a problem. Their donors just love to get every update and every story. In fact, their monthly donors tend to be the most responsive groups.

For other types of organizations, the once-a-year special strongest appeal and perhaps four newsletters a year with a soft ask through a reply envelope is the way to go. And of course, special event invitations are always good. The donors may not be able to come, but they’ll feel honored to be asked.

If you want to do it really right, consider a survey early on in the monthly donor relationship, and ask them how often they’d like to hear from you. You’ll be pleasantly surprised.

Ask for a legacy gift!

I figured Michael would especially like this one!

Monthly donors are six times more likely to leave your organization in their Will. They can only make small gifts now, but they’re investing in the organization. They’re committed for the short but especially for the long run!

However, you have to ask them to make that commitment. So, in your donor newsletter, put a story about a monthly donor who left you in their Will. Put a buck slip in the tax letter with the information the donor needs to give to their attorney. Include a question about leaving the organization in their Will in your online donor survey. Consider a special mailing with a specific ask to join the Legacy Society.

Plant the seeds and reap the rewards down the road.

All of these ways are going to make your (small) monthly donors become even more powerful, while increasing retention and life-time-value. All you have to do is ask (nicely!).


Well, as you’ve seen, I take requests. If there’s a question you have or topic you’d like me to address, please feel free to let me know. I’ll do my best to get you the answers and information that will help you be an even more successful fundraiser.

That’s what Erica Waasdorp and Michael Rosen say… What do you say?

7 Responses to “3 Powerful Ways to Get Your Monthly Donors to Give More”

  1. Thank you for sharing these suggestions, Michael. We have also found it productive to arrange for a major donor to challenge monthly donors and offer to match the annual value of new and increased monthly giving up to a certain maximum amount. This really motivates the monthly donors to, in effect, double their increased giving.

  2. As always, well-researched sound advice.

  3. KiMichael and Erica,
    Enjoyed the read today and appreciate the good advice. However, I was appalled to learn that some organizations increase the donor’s giving without their permission or knowledge. An organization that did that to me would lose my support as soon as I found out, just as certain banks and other businesses have found out doing the same thing.

  4. This was really helpful and I appreciate all the suggestions. We started a monthly giving program two years ago and haven’t asked for upgrades yet because I wasn’t sure how to go about it. Thank you for the timely advice!

    • Katherine, thank you for letting Erica and I know that this post was helpful for you. I wish you best as you seek to upgrade the support of your monthly donors. Let me know how it works for you.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: